Posts

Showing posts with the label Legal

Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021

 Introduction: What is an Intermediary The term ‘Intermediary’ has been defined in clause (w) of sub-section 1 of section 2 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (“ IT Act”) as “any person who on behalf of another person receives, stores or transmits an electronic record or provides any service with respect to that record and includes telecom service providers, network service providers, internet service providers, web-hosting service providers, search engines, online payment sites, online-auction sites, online-market places and cyber cafes”. This is a very broad definition. This not only covers social media companies (e.g., Facebook, Twitter) but also a wide range of players in the internet ecosystem including search engines (Google Inc., Yahoo Inc.), online payment sites (Paypal, Phonepe), online-market place (Amazon, Flipkart), telecom service providers (Jio, Vi), and cyber-cafes. The definition applies to any company where the user has an identity in the intermediary in fo...

Dispensation of shareholders’ and creditors’ meetings for listed entities in amalgamation proceedings

 With many wholly owned subsidiary companies merging with their listed holding companies, there were differing views on whether the meetings of the shareholders and the creditors of such listed entities are necessarily required to be conducted or they can be dispensed with. The rationale for this was also in question since the merger was only between wholly owned subsidiaries with their holding companies where there was no dilution in the shareholding of the listed entity nor was there a compromise with the creditors of the holding company. Read More: https://tlegal.com/blog-details/dispensation-of-shareholders-and-creditors-meetings-for-listed-entities-in-amalgamation-proceedings Relevant Provisions Before proceeding to discuss the recent judicial precedents, it is helpful to take a glance at the relevant provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 (“ Act ”). In terms of the Section 230(1) of the Act, for a compromise or arrangement to be fructified, a meeting of creditors or cla...

Explainer | Vijay Madanlal Choudhary and Others v. Union of India and Others

 In July 2022, the Indian Supreme Court (“SC”) pronounced its judgment[1] (“Judgment”) in a batch of writ petitions challenging the various provisions of the statute, namely, the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (“PMLA”). This article aims to summarise the history of PMLA, reasons for challenging the said statute, the decision of the SC, and its implications. Read More: https://tlegal.com/blog-details/explainer-or-vijay-madanlal-choudhary-and-others-v-union-of-india-and-others Historical Context The history of the PMLA can be traced back to the later part of the 1980s, when an urgent need was felt among various nations to protect their financial systems from money-laundering. In 1990, the United Nations General Assembly[2] called upon its member nations to develop mechanisms to prevent financial institutions from crumbling due to money-laundering, and to achieve the same by enacting laws in the respective countries. Eventually, in 1998, the United Nations in the ‘Speci...

Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021: Adequate Regulation of Intermediaries?

 The term ‘Intermediary’ has been defined in clause (w) of sub-section 1 of section 2 of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (“  IT Act ”) as “ any person who on behalf of another person receives, stores or transmits an electronic record or provides any service with respect to that record and includes telecom service providers, network service providers, internet service providers, web-hosting service providers, search engines, online payment sites, online-auction sites, online-market places and cyber cafes ”. This is a very broad definition. This not only covers social media companies (e.g., Facebook, Twitter) but also a wide range of players in the internet ecosystem including search engines (Google Inc., Yahoo Inc.), online payment sites (Paypal, Phonepe), online-market place (Amazon, Flipkart), telecom service providers (Jio, Vi), and cyber-cafes. The definition applies to any company where the user has an identity in the intermediary in form of a unique account/number ...

The Doctrine of Group of Companies: A Modern Approach to Consent in Arbitration Proceedings?

 Party autonomy is a foundational pillar in arbitration proceedings. An arbitration agreement reflects the parties’ willingness to be legally bound within the contours of that agreement. That is to say that parties to an arbitration agreement mutually consent to bestow jurisdiction upon a court and/or tribunal to decide certain disputes by their choice of law. However, in recent demanding times, in order to meet the ends of justice, courts and tribunals, under certain exceptional circumstances, have allowed extension of arbitration agreements to bind non-signatories. This article seeks to briefly review such exceptional circumstances under which courts and tribunals have approved joinder of non-signatories as party to the arbitration agreement by invoking the Group of Companies doctrine and the implications drawn by such joinder in absence of consent to be bound by the arbitration agreement. APPLICATION OF THE DOCTRINE IN ARBITRATION PROCEEDINGS In broad terms, the doctrine i...

ARBITRABILITY OF ANTI-COMPETITIVE DISPUTES

 Globalization has brought about significant changes in the world, leading to the dissipation of borders between nations and creating opportunities for economic development. While globalization has facilitated increased revenue and trade on a global scale, it has also resulted in inequality, particularly for developing countries that lack the necessary infrastructure to harness the benefits of an integrated economic market. These countries often need to seek technical knowledge, infrastructure, and financial advice from companies established in developed nations, which may lead to excessive borrowing and investments that could result in an unsustainable infrastructure. This unequal playing field in the global economy has resulted in anti-competitive practices and legal disputes arising from said practices. One such legal dispute is the  Future Retail Limited 1 case, which was filed by Amazon before the Supreme Court to enforce the emergency arbitrator’s interim order dated O...

A step back: reconsideration of the resolution plan by the CoC

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016  (“Code” ) was enacted  inter-alia  with an aim to resolve and reorganise the corporate debtor’s insolvency in a timely manner for maximisation of value of its assets. To accomplish the objectives laid down under the Code, a comprehensive step-by-step process is provided right from the moment of default till its realisation. One of the most crucial stages in the entire corporate insolvency resolution process (“ CIRP ”) is the approval of the resolution plan by the Committee of Creditors (" CoC ”) as the same is a deciding factor of how the insolvency of the corporate debtor would be resolved. While considering a resolution plan, the CoC considers several factors and after exercising its commercial wisdom, approves or rejects a resolution plan. Only after the assent of the CoC by voting of not less than sixty-six percent of voting shares, the resolution plan is approved in terms of Section 30(4) of the Code. The Hon’ble Supreme Court ...

NEW ODI REGIME | EFFECT ON CROSS BORDER STRUCTURING

  Following the overhaul of the foreign investment regime through introduction of the non-debt instrument rules, Ministry of Finance also attempted to overhaul the overseas investment regime. On August 22, 2022, Ministry of Finance notified: (a) Foreign Exchange Management (Overseas Investment) Rules, 2022 (“OI Rules”) in supersession of the earlier regime, i.e. (i) the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Any Foreign Security) Regulations, 2004; and (ii) the Foreign Exchange Management (Acquisition and Transfer of Immovable Property Outside India) Regulations, 2015 (together “Old ODI Regime”). Immediately thereafter, the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”) also notified Foreign Exchange Management (Overseas Investment) Regulations, 2022 and Foreign Exchange Management (Overseas Investment) Directions, 2022. (collectively, and along with OI Rules, “New ODI Regime”). While the New ODI Regime brought about significant changes, the most critical revision for the new age Ind...

EXECUTION OF DECREE

 The word ‘Decree’ (1) often appears along with the word ‘Judgment’ in Civil Courts, exercising the original jurisdiction. A Decree is passed after the final adjudication of disputes between the parties and, the law governing the aspect of Execution of Decree is prescribed under the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (‘ Code’ ) from Sections 36 to 74, 82, 135 and Order XXI (Rules 1 to 106) of the Code. Similarly, the Award passed by an Arbitral Tribunal is also deemed to be a Decree of a Court and can be executed as a Decree under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (‘ Act’ ) (2). Thus, the Award can be filed for execution before the Court where the assets of the judgment debtor are located as per the procedures established under the Code. General Principles While referring to Execution, the reservoir of power of Courts in executing the Decrees or Orders is contemplated under Section 51 of the Code. The magnitude of powers conferred to the Court under Section 51 of the Code are...

Implications arising from SGCA’s approach in Anupam Mittal case in future arbitration proceedings

Singapore Court of Appeal  (“SGCA”)  in the case of  Mittal v. Westbridge  (1) upheld the anti-suit injunction against the National Company Law Tribunal  (“NCLT”)  proceeding initiated by Mr. Anupam Mittal  (“Mr. Mittal") . The case revolves around the oppression and mismanagement  (“O&M”)  grievance raised in a company petition filed by Mr. Mittal before the NCLT against Westbridge. Westbridge secured an  ex-parte  anti-suit injunction against the said proceedings on the grounds that the cause of action arose from the shareholder’s agreement between the parties, which contained an arbitration clause and hence the present matter was under the purview of an arbitration agreement. Mr. Mittal challenged the said injunction in SGCA on the grounds that O&M matters are not arbitrable under the Indian Law and hence such matter does not fall under the purview of an arbitration agreement. SGCA upheld the anti-suit injunction...

ANALYSIS OF CONCEPT OF MATERIALITY

In recent years, India has witnessed a significant surge in investments across various sectors, marking a promising trend for the country's economic growth.1 This increase in investments can be attributed to several factors, including the Indian government's proactive efforts to improve the ease of doing business and implement investor-friendly policies such as the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 which has simplified the tax structure, making it more transparent and investor-friendly. Additionally, the Indian government has introduced amendments to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 in subsequent years thus streamlining the process of resolving insolvency issues and enhancing creditor rights. The Government has relaxed foreign investment guidelines which in turn has promoted foreign direct investment. Additionally, India's burgeoning consumer market driven by the upper middle class, skilled workforce, and a growing appetite for innovation have attracted both domest...

Guidelines on Default Loss Guarantee in Digital Lending

 The digital lending sector has received a significant boost from the Reserve Bank of India (“ RBI ”) through its recently issued Guidelines on Default Loss Guarantee in Digital Lending (“ DLG Guidelines ”) on June 8, 2023. These guidelines outline the terms and conditions governing the ability of RBI-regulated lending entities (“ RE ”) to engage in default loss guarantee (“ DLG ”) agreements with each other or with lending service providers (“ LSP ”). The DLG Guidelines have been introduced following extensive discussions between RBI and the fintech industry. This follows RBI's earlier decision to categorize guarantee arrangements between LSPs and REs as “synthetic securitisation” , which had raised concerns that DLG arrangements might not be permissible in the digital lending environment. The terminology concerning loss-sharing models has posed a challenge for the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) for quite some time. Following the issuance of the Guidelines on Digital Lending on Sep...

Dissolution of Partnership and Immovable Property

In this article, I examine the treatment of immovable property of a partnership firm, in view of various dissolution scenarios. Statutory Framework Section 14 of the Partnership Act, 1932 (“ Partnership Act ”) talks of the property of the firm, which include property (a) brought in by the partners, and (b) acquired by or for the firm, for its business (including the goodwill of the business). In this regard, unless stated otherwise, any property acquired from funds of the firm shall be deemed to have been acquired for the firm. Section 48 of the Partnership Act talks of settlement of accounts upon dissolution of the firm. For the purposes of this article, sub-section (b) talks of assets of the firm, and that upon paying (i) debts of the firm, (ii) the partners, (what they are due for advances as distinguished from capital, and on account of capital. Thereafter, the residue will be divided among the partners in proportion to the profit sharing ratio. Read More: https://tlegal.co...

THE RIGHT TO REMAIN SILENT UNDER THE PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT, 2002

 Article 20(3) of the Indian Constitution protects accused persons from being compelled to make self-incriminatory statements. The protection from self-incrimination along with the protection from double jeopardy as enshrined under Article 20(2) of the Constitution forms the fulcrum of the criminal justice system in India. As a necessary corollary, any confessional statement made before a police officer or out of coercion during criminal proceedings is inadmissible as evidence, and the same has been cemented in Sections 24 to 26 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (“Evidence Act”). The provisions under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (“PMLA”) take a sharp deviation from the constitutional protection from self-incrimination. The vires of the said provisions, among others, were challenged before the Indian Supreme Court (“SC”). The SC settled the issue by way of its decision in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary and Others v. Union of India and Others (“Judgment”), after almost a d...

Exploring Unchartered Territory? – Laws for the Void

  This 2 part series outlines the regulatory regime involving private sector participation in the space sector. This article explores the changes in the regulatory regime and the next one will explore the key challenges faced by private players (both domestic and international) in the Indian space sector.   What can the Indian space sector learn from the Avengers? Besides, the incredible budget and scale, the key takeaway would be - bringing experts together to achieve phenomenal results. We all remember the fascinating back stories, the strength of and the role each member plays to fill an essential need under the able guidance of a strong leader. The moment when the team does come together lights up the screen and assures the audience that all will be well. It isn’t all that different from how one may feel about India’s space journey. To build on this excitement, the Indian space sector needs the support of the regulations, patience from the private sector, and a unified vis...